Saturday, May 14, 2011

Move along folks. Nothing to see here.

click for larger
I have a saying that inevitably comes up when I talk about patents for long enough: When the government is deciding whether to grant a patent, "Is this a good idea?" is not a check box that has to be filled in yes/no. It's just not a requirement. And this is an amazing example of that from 1882. Props go out to Melissa for showing it to me. GOOD WORK! Reason for Awesomeness 1: The date, Dec 26th, 1882. The day after Christmas. 1882 was also the year Jesse James was shot, for perspective.




  
click for larger

Reason for Awesomeness 2: Why did he chose a tiny, cute field mouse for the animal to kill? Why not a big rat or a raccoon? The inventor, James Williams, is from Fredonia, Texas. And I have to imagine that Texas had better stuff to shoot at in 1882. It really does put the meaning in the word "overkill."

click for larger




Reason for Awesomeness 3: "This invention may also be used in connection with a door or window, so as to kill any person or thing opening the door or window to which it is attached." (highlighted right). Again, 1882 was the year Jesse James was shot. My mind is blown like a guy who got drunk and forgot he set one of these bad boys up in his barn.

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Before there was Tiger Blood, there was only Tiger Balm

Click for a larger copy
Per standard Patent Office practice, I present Charlie Sheen's patent: Chapstick Dispensing Apparatus. I say "per standard practice" because, like the USPTO, I'm getting around to this long after everyone else stopped caring about it. For the Office that usually means two years late, but with Charlie Sheen a few weeks appear to have been enough. That's more than enough time for him to get boo'ed off the stage in Detroit and all of his (un-paid) friends to abandon him to the wolves. And in case you didn't know, Sheen's real name is Carlos Irwin Estevez, as evidenced by this patent.

Honestly there's not too much to say about this beyond the fact that Sheen has a patent. It's not as awesome as van Halen's but the subject is much more odd. I guess we know what he talks about when he's finally crashed after a 72 hour drug induced sex-fest with whoever he's paying to tag along with him this month. "Hey baby. I know you're tired and probably worried about getting a UTI but I've got this idea for a rad chapstick holding devices for next time we're in the Bahamas." Don't get me wrong: I'm not judging him for those 72 hour drug induced sex-fests. If anything my sarcasm hides a little jealousy. My bet is most guys won't deny it if they're honest. In any case, it's just a chapstick container that has an attached cap, "tactile protrusions" (element number 130) on the side so it is easier to grip, and a place to attach a lanyard. I guess doing coke by ounce makes it tough to hold onto your lip balm after a while.

Click for a larger copy
The cap has a "finger-engaging cradle 102 [attached to] the top cap 100 by a living hinge." By the way, a "living hinge" is a real thing. It's a hinge formed from an integral thin band of material bridging between two thicker materials as opposed to two separate elements joined by a pin, like a door hing.

The patent also goes to great lengths to describe the problems with prior lip balms as highlighted to the right. It's worth reading.

On a more procedural note, work has been kicking my ass recently, and these posts take more time to write up than I'd originally thought. So I apologize about the slow pace of updates. And in the event you did get the "tiger balm" reference in the title and still read this far, I commend you and suggest you watch this.

Saturday, March 12, 2011

1. Open Box, 2. Discard Contents, 3. Give Box to Cat

Click for a larger copy

Those who know me well will know I have a bit of a soft spot for cats. There, I said it and I said it on the internet so it must be true. And I've taken more than a little shit in my life for being a heterosexual male who much prefers cats to dogs although I never quite understood why.

Oh wait, I forgot: Cat lovers can be some of the oddest people on Earth. See Exhibit A to the right.

Now I don't claim to be unveiling a long kept secret here, but cats fucking love cardboard boxes like dogs love chasing after balls you throw into a lake. I have absolutely no explanation for it, but it has been true of every cat I've ever known (not "known" in the Biblical sense).

And as someone who makes a lot of online purchases, my cats are always rich in cardboard boxes of every imaginable size and shape. This is the point where one would expect me to provide a link to my companion, cat-based blog "Feline 1" which recounts in unending detail the lives of my two cats, Benito Meowsolini and Eva Purrón, but I am not going do that because no such  blog exists and anyone who tells you otherwise is a God damn oath-breaking liar that you should never trust under any circumstances ever.
Click for a larger copy








The drawings are my personal favorite, as usual. Click on the images to the left for a larger copy. It's simple enough that very little elaboration on my part is necessary. It's a cardboard box with a hole in the top and sides, and the sides have a carnival-esque character portrait cutout that the cat sticks its head through. Cat goes in box and hilarity ensues.









What is interesting on a more detailed level is what the patentee regards as their "invention" in this case. I've highlighted it in the image to the right. What has been changed from a cardboard box with holes in 5 of its 6 sides to warrant the issue of patent protection? Does drawing or painting on an existing object alter that object sufficiently to be warranted being called something different? What does simple embellishment create? Thank you for your time and please Exit Through the Gift Shop.


The legalese here must really be respected. A "rectilinear configuration" with a "front face, left face, right face, and rear face." Yea gods, man: you've invented a cube! But wait, these faces have "indicia" and "motifs" on them. But the question remains: does changing the design of an object render it an invention patentable under US law? The question is not one I can voice an opinion on (damn you ethical restrictions! *shakes fist at sky*) but the fact remains that once an application issues as a patent, there is a "strong assumption" that it is valid. That means that it is much harder to invalidate an issued patent than to prevent something from issuing in the first place. But it's also important to remember that a patent is only worth something once you enforce it against someone (read: sue someone), and the courts may disagree with you. So it's always a tricky proposition in the end.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Could you put that cactus closer to my eye please?

When I hear the words "Greenhouse Helmet" I get an odd combination of Pauly Shore, Logan's Run, and Water World in my mind. It's something I picture as having the potential of being good, but actually being an utterly terrible idea for a wide variety of obvious reasons. What about Pauly Shore, Logan's Run and Water World is good and what is bad, either together or apart, I hear you ask? Well that's up to you.


This is remarkably simple in the overall context of patents. It consists of "a transparent dome completely over the head of a person." In this dome, there are shelves where plants are anchored to process the CO2 you exhale and provide you with O2 in an "economical and simple" way. Done and done.


**wipe your hands on your  jeans and exit stage left**


This patent is a small work of art in a vast sea of lesser patents. I say this because, in my personal opinion, it raises far more questions than it could ever hope to answer.



For example: Why, in the wide swath of life which falls under the umbrella of  "small plants," did Waldemar Anguita of Brooklyn N.Y. choose cacti as being the example for plants to secure to a shelf, right by your face? It was a choice, understand. Someone looked at this drawings and thought, "Yep, that is what we are going for."



The action taking place in fig. 1 to the left (click on the picture for a larger version) can only be described as 'jogging' or "calisthenics.' I honestly find it difficult to not be insultingly sarcastic while looking at this product of 1986 from the perspective of 2011. And yes, I'm aware that the perspective on now will be the same from 2036. Deal with it because we are all guilty.

I also can not help but respect the absurdity of the claims (what are the claims?), highlighted to the right. Click on the image for a larger version.

Claim 1: "A greenhouse helment which comprises:
(a) a transparent dome worn completely over the head of a person [read: a plastic fish bowl];

(b) means for securing said dome to said person [read: a chin strap];

(c) means for adequately filtering ambient air having carbon dioxide in and out of said dome to meet the needs of the person [read: the person has enough air];

(d) means for resting at least one plant within a pot placed in said dome so that carbon dioxide of said ambient air will mix with carbon dioxide breathed out by said person to be used by said plant to produce oxygen to be breathed in by said person in addition to the ambient air [read: there's a shelf to put plants on];

(e) means for securing said plants and pot upon said resting means within said dome [read: the plants are 'secured' to the shelf].

The patent coverage ran out in 2006, so your generic brand Greenhouse Helmets can come out of the black market garage sales and out into the daylight of late-night infomercials. May God continue to bless America.

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Wretched mortals, prepare your faces for melting

Bow thine heads unworthy, for ye are in the presence of a Rock God. US 4,656,917 issued to one Edward L. Van Halen of Los Angeles, California in the year of our Lord, nineteen and eighty-seven.


The most important thing to say is that this might be the single best patent cover figure I've personally seen. A line drawing of a major musician shredding on the cover of a US legal document is not something that happens very often.

So somewhere between doing stuff like this and kicking David Lee Roth out of the band, Halen filed an application for this patent. It's pretty simple, really: a flap on the bottom of the guitar folds open and supports the guitar horizontally which, according to the abstract "[allows] the player to create new techniques and sounds previously unknown to any player." So show some respect swine and spark your lighter, damn it!











It's not the only one Halen has either. He has a design patent for pegheads as well as a drop key tuning system. Good for him.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

How to read a patent

So what's this all about? Well, I come across a bunch of funny, weird, interesting, or just neat patents in my job. They seem to be a big hit with people, ergo I am writing this blog. Because patents are a fairly complex legal document, as an initial formality I'm going to go over how to read one. Don't worry, I'm not planning on being this detailed usually.

There are three basic parts to a patent. The first are the figures. Those are obvious. The second is the specification or the disclosure (read: the words). They describe the invention. The third are the claims. The claims are at the very end of the document and the most important part, legally speaking. They lay out what the patent holder wants for legal coverage, or the right to exclude others from making/selling/etc.

So the patent to the right is US 5,311,807, issued May 17th 1994 to Gottlieb Ruttgerodt of Germany. You can find the whole document here on Google Patents. This is the cover sheet where I've put some markers.

1: The patent number. Numbers are given in sequential order and are currently in the ~7,600,000s or thereabout
2: The first named Inventor from the application. If there are multiple inventors they're listed as Smith et al. which means "Smith and the rest"
3: The title of the patent. This one is "Military Tank" for obvious reasons
4: The full list of Inventors and the Assignee (read: owner) of the patent.
5: The classification of the patent. Every patent is categorized when it issues to aid in examination. This one is in class 89 (Ordinance), subclass 36.08 (Capping and Uncapping which is a specific manner of ammunition loading).
6: The Examiner of the patent. An "Assistant Examiner" listing means that the "assistant" actually examined the application (read: did all the work) and the "primary examiner" just signed off on it. So it goes.

After the cover page, the figures are shown as here on the left. Everything the Applicants want legal protection for must be shown and identified with a number in the figures. My brother engineers out there will recognize the style of drawing from their orthographic drawing classes in college.

After the drawings comes the body of the patent, called the specification, which described the invention in such a way as it allows the reader to make and use the invention. That's the quid pro quo aspect of the patent system. You as the inventor have to tell the Patent Office (and by extension, everyone else) how to make your invention, how to use your invention, and what it's good for. In exchange, the Patent Office gives you exclusive rights to that invention for a period no longer than 20 years. Using your disclosure, other inventors can work off your invention to further the state of the art. The term "art" is common and comes from the US Constitution which requires the creation of the Patent Office in Article 1, Section 8. Only the Patent Office and the Postal Service are explicitly created by the Constitution. Things people have done before are called "prior art."

At the end of the specification come the claims, marked by the arrow to the right. As mentioned above the claims determine what the patent holder actually gets legal protection for. They are written in extreme legalese. For example, the first claim of this patent reads:
"Claim 1: A military tank comprising: a chassis having a front half and a rear half having an upper surface; a turret; means mounting the turret for rotation on the upper surface of the rear half of the chassis; a heavy weapon; means mounting the weapon for pivotable movement on the turret" bla bla bla bla....

Think of it as the net that's being cast by the inventor. Any object which fits the description of the claims can only be made, sold, or used by the patent holder. What "fits the description" is up to a great deal of interpretation, which is why people sue each other. And that's basically it as far as the basic nuts-and-bolts of reading a patent. More to come.

So I do need to put down some CYA legal-type stuff too. I'll put it at the bottom to not scare anyone off. First, I am a patent examiner. That means ethically that I can't give any specific advice about applying for a patent other than say that you should retain the services of an attorney registered to practice before the US Patent Office. You can find a list here. I can talk about the application process in a broad sense, however. Second, so it's it writing, I'm not making any money off this blog, nor am I using my work computer to write it. While I do, of course, come across most of the patents I plan on writing about while at work, for the purposes of this blog all the patents are accessed via Google Patents. Third, while I can't really talk about the specifics of cases that I'm currently working on, patents issued off applications I've examined on are open to the public.